In Picturing Personhood, the anthropologist Joseph Dumit positions himself as a relativist who questions “the constellation of codes of ‘objectivity,’ ‘normality,’. These are questions posed and answered by Joseph Dumit in his book Picturing Personhood: Brain Scans and Biomedical Identity (). Positron Emission Tomography (PET) scans are currently used by the popular press and the entertainment industry to provoke great excitement.
|Country:||Moldova, Republic of|
|Published (Last):||19 May 2018|
|PDF File Size:||3.24 Mb|
|ePub File Size:||7.23 Mb|
|Price:||Free* [*Free Regsitration Required]|
Medicalization always clear and engaging. This the chapters are necessarily short c. Were they actively depressed while they were being scanned? Google contents of this website: The persuasiveness and truth status of these learned images before juries is an ongoing concern of the court. Alongside the social and institutional components of brain-fact production, we must face this question of how cultural identification and intuition coincide with these representations of reality so that we are persuaded to take them as true.
These images travel easily and are perssonhood made meaningful. I would argue that the application poor people themselves. Much of the disciplines of the history of science and science and technology studies STS concentrate on teasing out the difficulties of establishing facts in a particular place and time.
When did personhold first become possible to think of the brain as having distinct areas that can break or malfunction? Perhaps each slice has been chosen to emphasize the part of the brain implicated in the condition. In particular, I am working to locate contests over the true nature of human nature, sites where metaphors are incomplete or excessive and where they are changing. This time the balance is between the many kinds of audiences who will encounter these complex images: You take food in, you eat it, and it becomes nutrients for your cells.
Addressing such claims requires an ability to critically analyze how these brain images come to be taken as facts about the world–facts such as the apparent existence and ability to “diagnose” of these human kinds.
On the one hand, the PET community is small enough that it is impossible for me to relate specific histories of funding and publication without entering into the local controversies and violating anonymity requests.
Although there is no The book is made up of an introduction, question of the originality and pioneering which outlines main points of the history of nature of Picturing Personhood, future re- work on medicalization, masculinity stud- searchers must not lose sight of the histori- ies, and the social science of the body, and cal specificities of culture, nation, race, and eight subsequent pictuuring describing a range class when approaching imaging and other of empirical case studies on men and medi- medical technologies.
Surveying the history of the court’s use of images, from photographs to X-rays to computed tomography CT and PET, we can begin to understand how none of these images were immediately personood or understandable.
Select a default language
Second, I hope to foreground specific current directions of interdisciplinary and intersocial negotiations over the meaning and status of PET images in popular media, mental-illness communities, and courtrooms, in order to raise questions of how these practices might become social problems and begin a discussion on how they might be otherwise. Additionally, Sievert introduces her physical environment, sociocultural envi- own studies, carried out in the United States, ronment, and biology resulting in hot flashes Paraguay, Mexico, and Slovenia.
With the use of a cyclotron, radioactive isotopes of one of the four common biological atoms carbon, nitrogen, oxygen, and fluorine, the latter standing in for hydrogen are substituted for the original atoms in the molecule of interest. To introduce authentic and authoritative voices, Dumit conducts many interviews and lets experts of the participating disciplines talk for themselves.
These qualifications of brain imaging shake the authority that we tend to attribute to colorful pictures as telling a “true” and “real” story. The eryday life signals a shift toward a risk sexually functional male body is seen as a and surveillance society—that is, one orga- body or machine that responds immediately nized around tracking and managing risks.
I have chosen this anonymity to protect those who wished not to be quoted directly and also to evoke a range of positions within the PET community on different issues. In many cases, the researchers will continue to participate with journalists in constructing these stories because there are not many other ways to get the facts out.
Scientists take great pains to qualify the meaning of their images e. As it decays, the radioactivity is captured by the scanner and reconstructed in a map of the flow rate of the molecule. The challenge became to account both for the multiplicity of PET’s meanings and practices and for the powerful circulation of the images into different social arenas.
Google full text of our books: This has the odd medicalization with nuanced accounts of ac- effect of almost universalizing what are very ceptance and resistance cross-culturally and specific technologies and very specific con- over time.
Brain Scans and Americans have about who they are as per- Biomedical Identity. And I want to provoke discussion regarding this power. Nevertheless, popularization is not a simple one-way process of corrupting by dumbing down a scientific message.
Sample Chapter for Dumit, J.: Picturing Personhood: Brain Scans and Biomedical Identity.
Finally, there are definitions and demarcations of authority that interweave all of these–science versus personhkod culture, technology versus society, normal versus not normal–demarcations that are shorthand for the ways in which attributions of agencies, functions, and types are distributed, disputed, and constrained. And it might facilitate inter- empowerment. Brain Scans and Biomedical Identity.
Had they ever taken antidepressant medication? Behind our reading of these images are further questions of how these images were produced as part of a scientific experiment, and how they came then to be presented in a popular personhod so that they could be received by readers like us. The rapid increase emotions, and deny their pain.
However, normality can be a variety of things. The aim of this chapter is to systematically outline how and where these assumptions are built in so they can be tracked as the images travel. For him, medical science, technol- admitted them as authoritative evidence to ogy, and the self are co-constituted in mutual support the testimony of psychiatric experts.
As in analyses of ideology, the rightness of facts seems to emerge from our own experience. You image the radioactivity through time; you capture it with a ring of detectors. While representing a single slice of a particular person’s brain blood flow over a short period of time, one scan can also represent the pictjring flow of a type of humanbe used to demonstrate the viability of PET as a dujit technique, and demonstrate the general personjood of basic neuroscience research.
The qualifier usually must be emphasized, because most tests for biological conditions are not percent accurate. View freely available titles: